| • Shortlisted Ruth Schwartz Award for Children's Literature,
2001
The Toronto Star
"There's not an excess word in Reid's text. The
action licks along at a pace that can't help but hold
attention and Reid's trademark Plasticine art seems
to have reached a new pitch of vivacity and fun in the
pictures. It's impossible to tire of poring over all
the remarkable detail in this book"
The Vancouver Sun
"This kind of comic inversion, from the real to
the funny and familiar, is the key to Reid's modern
retelling. While the Grimm Brothers' version finishes
with a finger-wagging lesson about goodness, Reid's
comic characters bring the same message home with loads
more fun."
The
Hamilton Spectator
"In Golden Goose, she retells the old take
in two different ways. Her prose is straight-ahead,
and could have been adorned with the most traditional
of illustrations; instead she portrays the puzzled
father of the sad daughter as a stereotypical
small town car dealer and the boy as the youngest
son of a backwoods, Spam-eatin', trailer-trash,
wood-chopin' family. Reid is extra silly and sly
and there are things that amaze on every page..."
The Calgary Herald
Reid's Plasticine illustrations are a marvel,
chock full of humorous details and cleverly fashioned.
This traditional and fun-filled story is tuned
into the sensibilities of a generation of independent
and environmentally friendly children"
Resource Links
Barbara Reid is able to represent her characters'
personalities through her visual images as provokingly
as any verbal descriptions. It is a book with
an invitation to picked up and read. This is a
true picture book!
Although this book can be enjoyed on its own merit
as an entertaining story, it is also an excellent
accompaniment to the original version. For those
studying fractured fairy takes this book is a
wonderful addition. Older students could use this
type of text to inspire some wonderful pattern
writing of other folk tales.
This book, as other Barbara Reid takes, can open
an exploratory world of art to children. Not only
can they enjoy the story, they can use plasticine
to create their own characters, using the vivid
illustrations as a model. It is a picture book
that deserves to be in classrooms for many ages. |